Now I picked up Make up Forever's Smoky lash when I was in Paris. I promised myself I wouldn't use it until i finished a few other mascaras I was using. I have been using this mascara now on and off for a few weeks. I really like it, it really is a smoky lash. Whilst the mascara say its volumising, lengthening and curling I believe its more about volumising and curling the lashes.
The brush is quite chunky and I like that, because it really helps to create a dramatic look. One thing I found was the more you applied it began to clump the lashes and then started flaking off. I wasn't really impressed with that, but figured maybe less is more with this mascara. It separates the lashes pretty well again adding more drama.This mascara is meant to be extra black, but I don't think it's AS black as the MAC zoom fast black lash mascara is. It still has enough of an impact to it.
If you're after a volumous mascara this one would be perfect for you! I know a lot of people swear by this mascara and at 19 Euros it isn't cheap but one I would suggest giving a go!